As an inveterate buyer of second-hand books, I’m used to finding supplemental material inside. Usually it’s in the form of newspaper or magazine clippings, either a review of the book in question or an article about the author. Every once in a while they get a bit more esoteric—a travel article from the book’s setting, or something factual relating to the subject. But now thanks to The Book Bench, I know the practice has a history and a name: grangerization.
The term comes from James Granger’s 1769 Biographical History of England. The book was originally published as a two-volume set without illustrations, only a preface listing the portraits referenced inside. This set learned readers on a course of “extra-illustrating”: collecting artwork elsewhere, often cutting up other works, and having their books rebound with the new material. Whether or not the additions were improvements was open to debate; like their three-dimensional counterpart the Cabinet of Curiosities, grangerized books were most importantly an opportunity for collectors to show off their wealth and erudition:
In illustrating Washington Irving’s Life of Washington, for example, [Boston newspaper editor Curtis Guild] had gathered “autographic letters, choice old prints, plans, proclamations . . . and curious Revolutionary documents,” which by the end of the nineteenth century had become too scarce, because they had been “taken by collectors or museums, or have become lost or scattered.” Binding them into a book “in sumptuous dress” for his own private library seemed to a collector like Guild essential to “preserving” an orderly record of America’s past, even as it removed them from the public domain.
According to the American Antiquarian Society’s Common-place, by the end of the century print sellers were marketing sets of artwork specifically to grangerizers, keyed to various existing books—something like today’s scrapbooking empire, but with extra snob appeal. Even Mark Twain got in on the act, though he was a lot funnier than Martha Stewart:
I have invented and patented a new Scrap Book, not to make money out of it, but to economise the profanity of this country. You know that when the average man wants to put something in his scrap book he can’t find his paste—then he swears; or if he finds it, it is dried so hard that it is only fit to eat—then he swears… the result if barrels and barrels of profanity. This can all be saved and devoted to other irritating things, where it will do more real and lasting good, simply by substituting my self pasting Scrap Book for the old-fashioned one.
For anyone in the Washington, D.C. area over the next few months, the Folger Shakespeare Library has a show up on the topic, Extending the Book: The Art of Extra-Illustration, through May. It sounds like a neat exhibition, and a good opportunity to explore the Book Bench’s thesis: “In the end, there are good ruined books and bad ruined books, and the quality depends greatly on the artist. It depends a bit, too, on the beholder.”
(Mark Twain’s scrapbook advertisement courtesy of the American Antiquarian Society.)












